Navigate / search

Update on Lot Availability and Construction Lending “Location, location, location” is a truism associated with residential real estate. What we’re hearing from our construction contacts could be another sort of truism: “Labor, lumber, lots.” They are referring to the ongoing tight labor market in the construction trades, the skyrocketing price of lumber, and the difficulty of obtaining lots on which to build. While it’s true that housing sector fundamentals—employment growth, household formation, tight inventory—continue to support an optimistic outlook, our industry contacts continue to report challenges regarding the supply chain. This post will focus on lots in the Southeast. Data from MetroStudy indicate the supply of vacant developed lots in the Southeast has steadily declined since 2011 in absolute number and relative to housing starts (see the chart). While the current lot inventory appears similar to 2005 levels, there may be important differences. Anecdotal information indicates that lots are quite scarce, especially in desirable locations. That is, while the number of lots seems healthy, many of the lots developed from 2005 through 2007 were “bubble” lots—they have inferior locations and would not have been developed if not for the frothy environment of the time. When landing in Atlanta, for example, you can see scores of lots around the airport ready to go vertical, but being in the landing path of one of the world’s busiest airports does not make the location exactly “prime.” So, the number of lots may be overstated, and the need to develop lots in better locations persists. We heard of one possible roadblock from our business contacts. In the Atlanta Fed’s most recent Construction and Real Estate Survey, the majority of builders continued to report that the amount of available credit for construction and development was insufficient to meet demand. The difficulty in obtaining bank loans, a traditional source of funding for small developers, has made it challenging for them to convert raw land to buildable lots. Bank lending remains strong Given the comments on the survey, it seems somewhat surprising that, according to bank call reports, construction lending remains the highest growth portfolio among banks headquartered in the Atlanta Fed’s district (which encompasses Alabama, Florida, Georgia, and sections of Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee). Exposures for construction have risen steadily over the past three years as optimism about the economy has increased (see the table). [ Enlarge ] In 2005, before the banking downturn, over 80 percent of the banks in the district were reporting construction loan growth year over year, with median growth rates exceeding 40 percent. From the time of the banking downturn through the early recovery, however, construction loan growth turned negative. Banks experienced significant losses on partially finished projects, making them hesitant to lend on other projects. Growth finally turned positive again in 2014. From 2015 to 2017, the percentage of banks reporting year-over-year growth in construction increased slightly, from 61 percent to 65 percent. Still, the percentage of banks reporting growth in their residential construction portfolio has declined slightly while the overall growth rate of construction loans has dropped from 20 percent in 2014 to just over 13 percent as of December 31, 2017. Looking deeper into the primary drivers of loan growth, we broke down total construction lending into two categories: Residential 1–4 family construction loans and Other loans, all land development, and other land. Though the Other category includes all land development, it mostly includes only construction loans for nonresidential and multifamily properties. Loans for development of lots that will have one to four family houses built on them are routinely put in the Residential 1–4 family category of construction loans. What this means is that the data cannot tell us the amount of lending going to develop new lots. What the data can tell us is that overall construction lending is growing, though at a measured pace and starting from a relatively low level. And anecdotes tell us that the growth is not coming from lot development loans, but, rather, commercial real estate projects and “vertical” residential construction—that is, the actual building of houses. It is worthwhile noting that, as construction lending growth has progressed, construction as a percentage of capital has drifted towards the point such that the median level for all banks is approaching precrisis levels (see chart). So while construction loan growth is strong, our industry contacts continue to tell us that not much of that money is going toward lot development. Recent Senate action may make regulatory capital constraints less of a concern, so the smaller community banks in the district may increase construction lending. However, given conversations with banking experts, it does not appear that banks’ appetite for lot development loans has improved much since the crisis. Lots likely will remain relatively scarce, and our contacts will continue their lament of “labor, lumber, lots.” Robert Canova, senior financial specialist, Supervision, Regulation, and Credit Division, and Carl Hudson, director of the Center for Real Estate Analytics, both of the Atlanta Fed

Round and Round: The Basics of the Business Cycle

The FED Said The word cycle contains the notion of regularity. Yet one of the most important cycles of all, the business cycle, is anything but predictable. Plainly put, the business cycle is how economists refer to the inevitable ups—expansions— and downs—contractions, or recessions—of economic activity over time. But determining exactly when a cycle ends […] Read more

Special Report on the Affordable Housing Crisis

The FED Said From the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta A home is not just a place to lay your head at night. For many, it’s a sanctuary, an anchor, a sign of permanency and strength. A way to build wealth for owners. Across the Southeast, many individuals are struggling to find and afford a […] Read more

Seven in 10 Firms Sought Financial Help during the COVID-19 Crisis

The FED Said The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has had a shockingly large and swift impact on the U.S. economy since mid-March. And the initial coordinated federal response to the virus was, perhaps, equally swift, as Congress passed the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act by the end of March. Further evidence of the speed of […] Read more

Firms Expect Working from Home to Triple

The FED Said The coronavirus and efforts to mitigate its impact are having a transformative impact on many aspects of economic life, intensifying trends like shopping online rather than visiting brick-and-mortar stores and increasing the incidence of working from home. Indeed, many tech giants have already made working from home a permanent option for employees. Working from home, or telecommuting, is […] Read more

Beige Book: Economic Outlook Worsens as Coronavirus Forces Layoffs, Furloughs

The FED Said Economic activity in the Southeast dropped sharply from the middle of February through March as the COVID-19 pandemic spurred business shutdowns and job losses, according to the Federal Reserve’s latest Beige Book report on regional economic conditions. Across the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta’s coverage area, which includes the states of Alabama, Florida, Georgia, […] Read more

Regulators Move to Address Impact of Virus on Banks

The FED Said These are unprecedented times for our country. COVID-19 is affecting the economy, the banking system, and our daily lives. Our thoughts are with all those who are suffering, as well as those assisting them. Just like you, the well-being of our families, employees, and the public is our paramount concern. To this […] Read more

Regulators Move to Address Impact of Virus on Banks

The FED Said These are unprecedented times for our country. COVID-19 is affecting the economy, the banking system, and our daily lives. Our thoughts are with all those who are suffering, as well as those assisting them. Just like you, the well-being of our families, employees, and the public is our paramount concern. To this […] Read more

COVID-19, Workers, and Policy

The FED Said Workforce CurrentsStuart AndreasonMarch 18, 2020 As coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19) spreads around the world and across the United States, many policymakers and public health officials are encouraging employers to tell workers to work remotely or to stay home when they or their family members are sick. There are significant questions, though, about how […] Read more

LIBOR Transition—Ready or Not?

The FED Said What is LIBOR? Globally, the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR) has been used extensively as the benchmark rate for many financial transactions, from derivatives to loans to businesses and consumers. Estimates of U.S. Dollar (USD) denominated LIBOR exposure run as high as $200 trillion. Why is LIBOR going away? Since its inception […] Read more

Special Report on the Role of Small Business

The FED Said   Across the Southeast, the small business landscape is a tapestry of different stories that tell different experiences. Businesses with fewer than 500 employees entered 2019 with the tailwind of a strong 2018, as consumer spending picked up, corporate profits climbed, and the U.S. economy grew nearly 3 percent, as measured by […] Read more

CHILDHOOD: A SENSITIVE PERIOD FOR DEVELOPING WORKFORCE SKILLS

The FED Said Investing in America’s Workforce: Improving Outcomes for Workers and Employers Data show there is a sizable share of workers who have low skill and education levels. In 2016, 23.4 million adults aged 18 to 64 did not hold a high school degree or its equivalent—almost 12 percent of this age segment of […] Read more

Beige Book – Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta

The FED Said Summary of Economic Activity – Southeast On balance, economic activity in the Sixth District expanded at a modest pace since the previous report, and the outlook among contacts remained positive. Labor market tightness continued to limit growth in some sectors. Wage pressures persisted for lower-skilled positions, and some contacts expect higher wages […] Read more

Do Higher Wages Mean Higher Standards of Living?

 The FED Said A recent macroblog post used Atlanta Fed Wage Growth Tracker data to observe that the hourly wage of the lowest-paid workers has rebounded in recent years after declining for a decade. The chart below depicts this finding, showing the median hourly wage of the lowest-paid 25 percent of workers in the Tracker sample relative to the median […] Read more

Faster Wage Growth for the Lowest-Paid Workers

The FED Said On November 25, Fed chair Jay Powell gave a speech titled “Building on the Gains from the Long Expansion,” in which he observed that Recent years’ data paint a hopeful picture of more people in their prime years in the workforce and wages rising for low- and middle-income workers. In making this […] Read more